Skip to main content

CMB Data Analysis in the example of the POLARBEAR experiment and the LiteBIRD experiment

Author

Kolen Cheung

A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Physics

University of California, Berkeley, Fall 2022

Abstract

In this dissertation, I briefly go through my subject areas—from Astrophysics, Cosmology, to Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) radiation; and Data Science & High-Performance Computing. I go through the beginning of the Universe briefly in part I and introduce the Physics of the CMB in part II. Then I move on to how it can be observed experimentally, mathematically, and computationally in part III. In parts IV to VI, I write about 2 specific CMB experiments—POLARBEAR & LiteBIRD, together with my research involved in them.

In part V, original research on a measurement of the CMB \(B\)-mode at sub-degree scales is presented using the 3rd–5th seasons of POLARBEAR observations. This demonstrates the capability of a single medium aperture telescope with a Continuously Rotating Half-Wave Plate (CRHWP) to target both the low-\(\ell\) and high-\(\ell\) \(B\)-mode science at \(50 \leq \ell \leq 3000\).

In part VI, the effect of detector crosstalk systematics on the CMB power-spectra is studied in detail in the example of the LiteBIRD experiment. An analytical, map-domain solution is developed, a computational simulation method is implemented, and the two predictions are compared using the LiteBIRD experiment design specification. The general agreement of the two shows that the analytical model well describes the LiteBIRD experiment, and can be used to calculate the systematic effects without performing time-consuming time-domain simulations with a high degree of accuracy. This can be used to forecast the amount of crosstalk systematics and to develop mitigation strategies. A mitigation strategy is presented, which is a hardware-based mitigation method that minimizes the crosstalk systematic effects in the 2pt power-spectra.

While the author claims that this dissertation is original, unpublished, and is an independent work, only those in parts V and VI are original research. Other materials in parts I to IV are introductory materials summarizing well-known knowledge in the field. In particular, many plots, graphs and visualizations from these parts are from existing publications which should fall under “fair use” and are properly cited. There are a few exceptions that images are obtained through internal circulations including presentations from others in the collaborations where original source is not known. This is documented in References.

To Her

To my grandma Pick Yee Lau,
who chose to care for her small grandson over a surgery for full recovery of her leg.
To my mother Joyce Tsui,
who combats depression alone when her only son pursues a PhD study in a foreign country.
To my wife Ivy Cheung,
who sacrifices her career and follows me till the end of the world.
To my beloved Belle the cat,
who has accompanied me throughout my study, and is our only family in the US.
I miss you, grandma and Belle,
I wish you would be with me in the graduation,
and I look forward to meeting you again in the new heaven and new earth.

Acknowledgements

I thank my advisor Adrian Lee. Thank you for giving me the opportunity when no one else did. Thank you for keeping my position funded. Thank you for your patience. Thank you for teaching me to work academically. Thank you for your feedback on my dissertation on such a tight schedule. You have the ability to appreciate things when no one can and your smile is contagious.

I thank my co-advisor Julian Borrill, who suggested the structure of the presentation of my qualifying exam after a disastrous preparation. It continues to form the backbone of this dissertation. Thank you for the opportunity at the computational cosmology center (C3). Thank you for being straight to the point and be an example of how to get things done. Thank you for the wisdom you shared in casual conversations.

I thank Kathy Yelick who serves as the representative of my designated emphasis. Despite being so busy as the Associate Laboratory Director for Computing Sciences at LBNL, she did not hesitate to be on my qualifying exam and dissertation committee, and she offered to meet when I faced difficulties. Thank you for supporting my job hunt.

I thank my graduate advisor Holger Müller. Without your dedicated work on my case, I would not have even started the research in this dissertation, let alone finish it. Thank you for your kindness, listening, and understanding. We need more people like you, who listen. You are my role model in how I treat others.

I thank Matt Pyle for his positivity who serves on my qualifying exam and dissertation committee. Thank you for your interesting questions which refine my dissertation. I thank Uros Seljak who serves on my qualifying exam committee. Thank you for having to participate twice in my presentations.

I thank the many people that I worked with in POLARBEAR. Thank you Akito Kusaka who prepared me by foretelling how long it would take me to graduate when I make the jump to this field. Thank you for your insights—it is eyeopening to watch you ask questions in any kinds of meetings. Your process of asking questions while thinking out loud is almost like a master class showing exactly how we should think when new research is presented to us. Thank you Christian Reichardt for all the insights in CMB analysis and your advice to spend time wisely in managing my research. Thank you Yuji Chinone for your mentorship. Despite our differences, I know you care about our research. Thank you Neil Goeckner-Wald, thanks for all the wonderful ideas and insights you shared. Thank you for all the hard work. You are smart and yet humble.

I also thank the people from the C3. Thank you Ted Kisner and Reijo Keskitalo who shows me how CMB data analysis should be carried out properly. Thank you Reijo for all the little things you shared, from personal to research experiences. Thank you Giuseppe Puglisi for your work on LiteBIRD where my research has benefited from. I cannot believe the day I told you “I’m going to see you tomorrow” before the COVID lockdown is the last day we met. I hope to meet you again soon.

I would also like to thank all the people who have inspired me and shaped me to become who I am. Thank you Wong Wai Kay, a senior schoolmate in SYSS. Thank you for introducing me to all those wonderful books in mathematics, and taught me how to play international bridge. All these shaped the way I think to this day. Thank you, my math teacher Mr. Wong Chi Shing from SYSS. Your exposition on mathematics as the universal language shaped how I appreciate mathematics till this day. Thank you, my English teacher Mr. Keith Chan from CHECSS. You are a uniquely caring teacher who taught us life lessons through teaching English. I hope I lived up to your expectation to no longer be a self-centered person. I thank Prof. Yang Zhiyu and Prof. Ng Tai Kai from HKUST. I thank for all the opportunities related to the physics olympiads without which I would not be doing this today. Thank you Prof. Shengwang Du from HKUST for sharing your experience in finding research project in graduate school and your worldview. Both are contributing factors into how I became a CMB physicist. Thank you James Chu, a lovely elder who inspires young people, and a fellow physicist. I should have listened to your advice earlier, and not clung onto being a theorist. Thank you Ted Peng for sharing an inspiration from a CMB physicist in 2010. And little did I know, one day I would become a CMB physicist myself!

I thank a lifelong schoolmate, Lokman Tsui. We shared the same primary school, secondary school, undergraduate school, and graduate school. We became companions since the day we met in physics olympiads. At a time we were to conquer String Theory together. I wish we could have cracked it. I miss you in the academia.

Lastly, I thank all my loved ones—my grandma, my mother, my wife, my soon-to-be born baby, and our cat Belle. This dissertation is dedicated to you. I thank my father, who gives me all the freedom I need to make any decision I like. I also thank my aunt Tsui Sau Hing who should receive sainthood for being the last person who still cares for my mother. She is the only reason I can stop worrying about my mother and focus on my study abroad. I thank my uncle General Cheung, he treated me like his son when I was young. I still kept the notebook he bought me when I first studied abroad at UCB. I have to thank my wife Ivy Cheung again, who directly contributed to the successful completion of this dissertation. How can I live without you? It broke my heart when you chopped your finger accidentally on the day the COVID lockdown started. Thanks for taking care of me all these years. Thanks for enduring this ridiculous country where one holding an F2 spouse visa is not allowed to work. Thanks for suffering in the broken US medical system where you cannot even get to see a doctor between my graduation and our departure of the US. I am thankful we are getting out of here, as you always said we will one day do. Thanks for letting me learn how to love. Thanks for being poor with me. Thanks for burning the midnight oil with me, but seriously, you cannot do this anymore. Thanks for cooking so much good food for me, making me a proper US-sized person. Thanks for pushing me to relax more and enjoy life once in a while. Thanks for keeping me down-to-earth when I always dream big. Thanks for listening to me explaining physics to you. I know you enjoy how soothing it is to you too, helping you fall asleep faster than any medicine.