Skip to main content

31 Our measurement

Keywords

POLARBEAR, Power spectra, Likelihood and inference, Null tests, Foregrounds, Gravitational lensing, Cosmological parameters, Calibration, Simulations

31 Our measurement

In null-test v0.13.41, 24 \(T, E\) noiseless simulations and 24 \(T, B\) noiseless simulations are used to estimate the filter transfer functions. 48 \(T, E, B\) with sign-flip noise simulations are used as MC simulations for the estimation of statistical properties including the error-bar. Null-test suite is passing preliminarily. Following the reasoning outlined in sec. 29.3, it is scaled up to a set of \(128, 128, 512\) simulations respectively in null-test v1.0.0.

The deconvolution problem mentioned in chapter 30 is fixed in v1.0.1. There is another minor problem concerning how the ground-template is constructed and is fixed in v1.0.2. This is the final analysis. Below are its null-statistics and the measurements.

The \(\ell\)-range for \(BB, EB, EE\) is 600–3000, using a bin-width of 100. The \(\ell\)-range for \(TT, TE, TB\) is 600–1600 instead as the \(T\)-filter transfer function has numerical stability issues above \(\ell \simeq 1600\).

31.1 Passing Null Test suite

\(\alpha = {5\,\%}\) is required in the null-test suite passing requirements.

For Kolmogorov–Smirnov test, when it is performed using null random variable \(χ(X, n, b)\) with \(X = BB, EB, EE\), overall p-value is \({13.0\,\%}\) with a confidence level of \(P(p > \alpha) = {99.9\,\%}\), estimated using \(1,000\) bootstrap.

Table 31.1: PTE for the null-statistics defined in definition 2 estimated using MC simulations.

power-spectra \(G_{Y_1}\) \(G_{Y_2}\) \(G_{Y_3}\) \(G_{Y_4}\) \(G_{Y_5}\)
BB 72.07% 81.25% 75.39% 85.74% 14.45%
EB 80.27% 37.30% 63.28% 27.93% 6.05%
EE 37.30% 83.20% 80.66% 98.44% 65.82%
TB 8.01% 41.02% 99.22% 81.45% 80.66%
TE 11.33% 81.45% 31.45% 88.67% 48.83%
TT 29.10% 84.77% 40.63% 94.53% 91.60%

Tbl. 31.1 shows the null-statistics as defined in definition 2 estimated using MC simulations. Using the 15 null-statistics with \(X = BB, EB, EE\), overall \(p\)-value is at \(α_c = {90.8\,\%}\) with a confidence level of \(P(p > \alpha) = {100\,\%}\), estimated using \(10,000\) bootstrap. This is the unblinding requirement.

For reference, if all \(30\) null-statistics with \(X = BB, EB, EE, TE, TB, TT\) are to be included, overall \(p\)-value is at \(α_c = {99.2\,\%}\) with a confidence level of \(P(p > \alpha) = {100\,\%}\), estimated using \(10,000\) bootstrap.

31.2 Likelihood & posterior

Method detailed in sec. 28.3 is followed to perform likelihood estimation.

Foreground model

Prior of dust foreground is included following the same model used in Sayre et al.2

\[D_\ell = A_{d, {150\,G\mathrm{Hz}}} \left(\frac{\ell}{80} \right)^{-0.58}.\]

A different Gaussian prior is used however, as a slightly different numerical value is found when it is derived from the source of the input in the model from Ade et al.34,

\[\begin{align*} \beta &= {1.59 \pm 0.11} \\ T &= {19.6\,\mathrm{K}} \\ A_{d, {353\,G\mathrm{Hz}}} &= {4.6 \pm 1.1} \\ \Rightarrow A_{d, {150\,G\mathrm{Hz}}} &= {0.009554078346271361 \pm 0.002907862359357405}. \end{align*}\]

Lastly, \(D_b \equiv \sum_\ell w_{b\ell}^{BB} D_\ell\).

Calibration / nuisance parameters

Using the likelihood procedure defined in sec. 28.3, an affine-invariant ensemble sampler for Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC)5 is used to estimate the posterior distribution of the input parameters.

The posterior distribution of \(A^\text{dust}_{\ell = 80; {150\,G\mathrm{Hz}}}\) is similar to the prior.

Regarding calibration parameters, the absolute gain of the intensity map is \(a_T = {1.091 \pm 0.012}\), and the absolute gain of the polarization maps is \(a_E = {1.107 \pm 0.013}\). The agreement of both means the polarization efficiency calibration is unbiased.

For the absolute angle calibration, \(\theta = {-0.32 \pm 0.19^\circ}\). For the \(\sigma^2\) parameter in the beam model, \(\sigma^2 = {0.48 \pm 0.19'}^2\).

These are consistent with the result from the large-patch low-\(\ell\) pipeline.6

Cosmological parameter

The cosmological parameter here is \(A_\text{lens}\) which is the ratio between the measured lensing \(B\)-mode and the theoretically expected amount of lensing. Hence, its fiducial value is \(1\). There are a couple of ways to interpret this result.

Starting with the MCMC chain, one can estimate that

\[P(A_\text{lens} > 0) = {99.6\,\%}.\]

Wilks’ theorem can also be used7 to convert the likelihood ratio to a probability of \(p = {99.2\,\%}\). The agreement between the two is reassuring, and the result from MCMC is used in the end as it makes no assumption on the behavior of the likelihood.

Lastly, \(A_\text{lens} = {3.90 \pm 1.51}\), where \(3.90\) is the MLE and \(1.51\) is the standard deviation. The two-sided \({90\,\%}\) CI is \(1.46 < A_\text{lens} < 6.42\), while the one-sided \({90\,\%}\) CI upper bound is \(A_\text{lens} < 5.85\).